
I'm sure that many of you are scratching your heads but please let me explain :D What with this site containing thousands of reviews for chocolates from all over the globe you can probably imagine that I get my fair share of e-mails and comments telling me that my views on a particular product are 'wrong'.
My response to 99.0% of these e-mails (if they are courteous enough to warrant one!), normally goes along the lines of "this is just my opinion" ... "there isn't the time in the world to re-review products" ... "they only get the one shot" etc.
There is one product however, that has managed to justify a second look at given the sheer amount of contact I have received about it's original review - see below. One ChocolateMission reader in particular (by the name of Patrick), felt so strongly that my original review was so wide off the mark, that he sent me a box (yes a box!) of these Nestle Coffee Crisp to give another try .... I had to oblige.
Since I last reviewed the product over a year ago, the packaging and presentation hadn't really changed. Aside from a tweaks to the on-pack graphics the bar looked no different from the last time I saw it - no differences there.
Piercing the film wrapper the smells of biscuity chocolate immediately suggested that a finer proposition may be at hand. Indeed, whilst the outer layer of milk chocolate was still criminally thin, it was at least fresher tasting and more forthcoming with it's sweet, milk based flavours. Breaking the bar in to pieces, the crisper, snapping sound of the wafer was evidence enough that this bar was in fact in ten times better condition than the one I tried for my last review. In addition to being superior in texture, the wheaty biscuit flavours were far more Kit Kat like, and obviously all the better for it. The coffee cream, whilst still underpowered for my taste, also offered a more in it's contribution to the taste with it's creamy cappuccino like influence. The bar in totality still wasn't the satisfying thing ever, but the greater flavour contribution certainly made it more fulfilling than the last time I reviewed it.
Overall this isn't the best chocolate bar in the world, but in life you sometimes just have to hold your hands up and say you got something wrong, and this is one of those instances for myself :D This bar was never worthy of the rating it originally received and I would now like to rescind that and replace it with the far more reflective score of 7.3 out of 10. Whilst I would say there is room for improvement with almost every component of the Coffee Crisp, the combination of them all do make for a tasty tasting wafer bar that is certainly worth a look at if you are a fan of Kit Kats and the such. So there you have it ChocolateMission readers :D you were all right .... now quit it with the e-mails :D about the damn Coffee Crisp haha!
7.3 out of 10

Original Post - October 17th 2009
Kcal 260 Fat 13.0g Fat(sats) 7.0g Carbs 34.0gThis has been a bar that has managed to allude me for quite a while though I kindly had one sent to me by ChocolateMission reader Eric last week. The Nestle Coffee Crisp is a product that doesn't come with any formal description on the wrapper though as you probably ascertained it is a wafer based bar with coffee creme filling, covered in milk chocolate. What the packaging did state was that the bar was produced in Switzerland which didn't surprise me all that much given that Nestle have such a strong presence in the country. Given my love for coffee flavoured chocolates I was well and truly looking forward to this one and devoured it during a mid morning coffee break.
For a wafer based bar I was surprised to see that it actually weighed 50.0g and amassed a rather large 260 calories and 13.0g of fat which kinda contradicted the on pack slogan of 'makes a nice light snack'. In regards to looks the product on the whole was presented pretty well. I didn't care much for the yellow film wrapper but at the same time it was distinctly Nestle like with its bold red branding. On closer inspection the bar itself had distinct layers of chocolate, wafer and inner creme, though it noticeably lacked a real aroma of real note apart from a very minor biscuit scent.
From the photo above you will be able to see the thinness of the outer chocolate layer so I guess it really wont surprise you to hear that it was really not that impactful in regards to flavour. The milk chocolate was pretty quick in its melt and it's milk chocolaty flavours felt like they were sucked up by the drier wafer as soon as they transcended into a liquor state. Where the chocolate was poor the wafer element was even worse - it was almost flavourless aside from a minor malt note and had a very stale like texture that yielded with very little crispness when bitten into. Had it not been for the relatively tasty coffee creme this bar would have been an absolute disaster but even that wasn't anything that special. Looking on the positive side of things the inner creme added a degree of welcome moistness to the reservoir dry wafer, as well as bringing a mild coffee influence to what on the whole was product severely lacking in flavour. Despite consuming the whole bar in one sitting I neither found that it fulfilled my hunger or left me wanting more - what a disappointment!
Overall I guess it says it all that I was reaching for the wrapper to check the best before date after only my first bite. Frankly I couldn't believe that Nestle could get a wafer based bar so wrong what with them being the kings of the sector with their glorious Kit Kat range. Conversely to the Kit Kat model this bar had a wafer thin layer of outer chocolate and criminally poor inner wafer that was not only horrible in terms of texture but also devoid of flavour almost completely. As I said in the paragraph above without the sound quality coffee creme layer this bar would have been an absolute car crash ... and we are talking pile up proportions here!! As you can probably tell this is not a bar I would have again in the near future and it is not one I would recommend you get involved with anytime soon. Even though I am a huge fan of coffee flavoured chocolate I can't defend this bar on any level, it is simply just really poor.
4.8 out of 10











42 comments:
Hi Jim,
Love reading your blog. :)
Must say, I'm a bit shocked at this review, especially at the part about how the wafer wasn't all that crisp. My partner and I both said that it sounds like you had a stale one, because in our experience, (Canadians with constant access to this bar) Coffee Crisp is so crispy that it sort of... explodes everywhere. Delicious and a huge mess.
Although... perhaps there's a different Coffee Crisp in Switzerland. If you would like (and if they are different), I would be glad to send you a Canadian Coffee Crisp for you to try. :)
-shasta, who does not work for Nestle but does eat a lot of chocolate.
I like the idea but it obviously hasn't been done very well. Nestle have a habit for doing that don't they.
It's a pity as this bar sounded quite interesting - of course, you just suggested a great idea jim - a coffee kitkat!! did you know they once had coffee aero's (aswell as lime, strawberry, and others!) i wish those days were still here - im far too young to even remember seeing them but they sound rather good lol!
And going off topic I thought you might like to see a pic of the much misssed Golden Cup!
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_htpVvj0sh1c/SsDhg7QpHlI/AAAAAAAACfU/7ikj7NZSQeM/s1600-h/ukrgol.jpg
They look like Blue Riband, yuk!
Do nestle still do the kit kat cappuccino?
I had one of these in America once and I can see what you mean about the wafer being not as crispy as you would expect because I thouhgt the same.
I can imagine it would be nice dipped in hot chocolate.
Wow 4.8 you seem to be getting one awful product a week at the moment Jim. You should be more selective of the stuff you review lol.
Rxxx
I must agree with Shasta. This is a very popular bar in Canada and those of us in the U.S. have had to import them because for whatever reason Nestle only briefly officially marketed them here. I can tell you that mine have always been very crispy and tasty. I hope you can get a Canadian Coffee Crisp to try.
I can't believe you rated this bar so low it is one of my all time favourites. I would take shasta up on that offer I want to see if you think differently about a pure Canadian bar.
Looking at the feedback Jim I think your should a re-review this one. It is obvious it just got one that had gone funky.
Maggs
Jim,
I think maybe you got a bad bar too. The one that I had (and the few that I have eaten since just because) had wonderfully crisp wafers. This is one I would try again.
Shasta
Hi there thanks for the first comment. Please make it a habit.
By the sounds of it I obviously came across a bar that wasn't at it's best.
If your offer is serious I would be very interested in taking it up. It would be great to see if there are any differences between the Swiss and the Canadia one. Drop me an e-mail if thats the ok but seriously don't feel obliged it is overly generous.
Don't worry I believe you don't wory for Nestle! They would be bothered by a small time guy like me :)
David
The concept is great but the bar I ate the execution was flawed.
Alan
Well they did do the cappuccino Kit Kat until a while ago didn't they. I have no idea if it is still out.
Those Aeros sound interesting I can't remember them myself. It is a shame they don't even do the orange aero anyone. Nice find with the pic but I still don't remember it I am afraid.
Phil
Unless I see Blue Ribands on a ridiculous offer I doubt they will make an appearance here so don't worry :D
Anon #1
No idea ... see above!
Steven
I like the idea about dipping it in hot chocoalte ... maybe I will give that a try if I try this one again!
Rachel
Hold your horses by the look of it I could have just got a duff one here. Trying bad products is unavoidable anyway given the amount I have to review.
Gary
Thanks for the post chap! Enough people today have questioned the quality of the bar I reviewed enough to make me curious enough to review it again! Thanks for the feedback it is always useful.
Brody & Maggs
Don't worry both of you I will be giving it another try!!
Gi
Your comment was the final nail in the coffee haha! I will definitely give this another try as I just read your own review. Sounds like I got one that wasn't in peak condition! This will be chocolatemission first ... a re-review!!
Thanks for all the feedback everyone. I will indeed like to review this bar again so I will try and get the wheels in motion. Thanks for all the polite comments ... in this sort of circumstance I would have expected some more 'ERRRR YAAAA WRONG!' comments :)
Jim
I have to disagree with this review completely - this is one of the best everyday bars out there but then, I am talking about the Canadian bars. I think the problem is that you just got a bad bar or the Swiss ones just don't measure up. The Canadian coffee crisps are crispy, flavorful, with a delicious mix of milky coffee and chocolate flavors - try a Canadian bar and I think you'll be delightfully surprised.
Elizabeth
Hi thanks for adding your POV. As I said above I am more than willing to give this one a another reviews given the responses I have recieved. I am really looking forward to try the Canadian bar when I get it.
Thanks
Jim
I thought I had seen this reviewed before :) I even commented on it last time you posted about it lol.
Its nice to know that you arent stubborn and can change your opinion. Better work on the pictures as well this time. Have you upgraded your camera or something?
This is one of the bars I always see them selling on the importer sites based here in England. I have fancied trying it a few times but have always been put off by the reviews I have read about it. I might give it a try next time I use one of them now. Thanks for the review, lol I mean re-review.
This still doesn't sound like my sort of chocolate bar but Im a bit more open to trying it than after your score of 4 :) 7 isn't a rating that is telling me I need to go out and buy it right away still though. It sounds distinctly average.
Rxxx
Im sorry to hear you get hassle off people for just having an opinion. That isn't fair of people to pick on you just because you run the site, we all say our two pennies worth nearly every day so if anything we should share your abuse lol. I still think your brilliant Jim don't worry :-)
Dx
This still looks like an over inflated Kit Kat to me. Its not a bar I would buy at any great expense, it looks like it should be a cheaper product like a Timeout or something.
Oh well well done for conceding you were wrong.
I never saw your 1st review so its interesting to see how you thought they were totally different from one time until another.
In this instance it does sound like it was more down to the freshness than anything else. It does make me wonder what other bars you should review again though.
Bravo Jim good call to give this another try. Lol I have never gone as far as emailing you about it, but I have previously read the review you wrote in 2008 and I thought you were wrong about it then.
Like you say its not a special bar or anything but its as good as any average wafer thing. The coffee needs to be stronger I can agree with you on that.
Why do you think they added that big tick on the wrapper? What does it indicate?
Whilst I would say there is room for improvement with almost every component of the Coffee Crisp, the combination of them all do make for a tasty tasting wafer bar that is certainly worth a look at if you are a fan of Kit Kats and the such. So there you have it ChocolateMission readers :D you were all right .... now quit it with the e-mails :D about the damn Coffee Crisp haha!
Brill! I can start spamming you about something else now ........ what to pick decisions decisions lol Perhaps I will email you about reviewing the Cadburys Dream chocolate again :-) I know you will definitely change your mind about that if I pester you J/K :-) :-)
A blogger willing to admit their POV is wrong? Am I not reading this correctly or something?
Well done Jim. Great article today.
This is a bar that I have bought a few times myself. I wouldn't say it is anything special but it is a nice enough option to buy if you like wafers and stuff like that. The coffee is always disappointingly weak imo.
Is it a good or bad thing that I remember the first time around you posted about this lol? Lets say it is a good thing and that im a dedicated readers of your's lol ;)
I appreciate that these things change from trying one thing one time to another. Do you mostly only get to try everything once then? It cant be the best way of testing things out but I see it can be unavoidable if your write every day like we know you do. I dont see a way you can get around it hmmmmm.
Mate I never saw the first post your wrote about this. Im shocked to think you ever said the coffee crisp was that bad. If I had seen it I would have put you straight without you needing to review it again.
Well done for admitting you were wrong mate. It takes courage to swallow your words and write something again like that.
Here was me thinking that you thought your word was final. I got a whole list of chocolates that I think you have given unfair reviews to. Problem is I think you have done this one again especially because people like me can see that you are normally against anything that nestle make. You have just done this to deflect attention haven't you. 7.3 is hardly going to encourage anyone to buy it but it covers your tracks. You are too obvious in what you do.
If it is like a Kit Kat then I am well in.
By the sounds of it, its like the old coffee kit kat that they made in the two fingers you could buy from supermarkets. I used to love them but Nestle stopped producing them for some reason :( Boooooo
I think I might have been one of the original people to ask you to review this again. It took you long enough to do it lol what was the delay?
When I got mail in my inbox I got a sense of deja vu. it is good to see im not going nuts and that you had reviewed it before lol.
I dont suppose you care at all jim but liverpool are playing some Romanian team tonight :) Torres and Gerrard aren't playing so we might be in a bit of trouble. I dont think I will even bother watching it lol.
I could do with one of these to go with my hot choccie. Brgggggggh its so cold.
Lol even your photos make it looks better this time around.
Despite you saying its a bit better Im still not convinced it would be worth buying. I dont get the people saying it looks like a Kit Kat. More like a blue riband to me.
Did you try the Swiss or the Canadian version?
I'm surprised people got in such an uproar over this. I mean is it really that special?
Still, good on you for admitting you got it wrong Jim.
@Alex - Seriously, what is your problem? Jim has rated plenty of Nestle products favourably. It's all in your head mate.
Well cudos for re-reviewing this bar and coming to a very different conclusion this time round! Rather interesting really since Nestle apparently didn't really change anything about the bar if I read correctly?
However, even with a seven before the comma for taste, it just doesn't appeal to me at all! I find it looks rather nasty. *g*
I backup what Daisy said. We're all entitled to our own opinions and I don't think Jim should be exempt from that just because he writes the reviews. I think he does a good job of remaining as impartial as possible, especially when compared to some blogs. If I were doing this I'd find it very difficult!
Well done for changing your review. If only other bloggers were as truthful as you.
What a lovely review, it's great that you decided to re-review this bar. However, you can now expect even more demands that you retry everything you give a disappointing score to haha. I missed this review 1st time round but had read it previously. I can't say it's a bar I recognise but if I come across it I'd definitely be interested in giving it a try, especially after the revised score. Thanks again for the review.
Lol I thought i was seeing double when I read the review :P it's interesting to see how different it tasted, it just shows how a 'bad' bar can put you off something purely by chance rather than it being a fundamentally bad bar if you see what I mean. Well done for giving it another chance, although as others have said I'm not sure what the fuss was for to start with lol
I'm intrigued by the new addition to the wrapper - that silly tick also reads next to it 'Crispy Wafer' - isnt that a really pointless addition?? lol although going on Jim,s original review the wafer wasnt very crispy before :P
Hi everyone,
Strange review this one today eh :D
It was nice to take the time to go back to something I had previously reviewed. It isn't something I will be making a habit of, but once and a while is ok if there are glaring errors you guys believe I have made.
David / James - Re: Have you upgraded your camera or something?
no upgrades on the camera chap. Just I shot it in different light etc. Admiteddly these ones look sharper.
Nick / Rachel/ Gary - RE: Is it worthy buying?
Its not a must try but worth a try if you like wafer based things.
Daisy - Re: Im sorry to hear you get hassle off people for just having an opinion. That isn't fair of people to pick on you just because you run the site
Dont worry about that I dont get too much flak. More praise than criticism :D :D
Kim - Re: It does make me wonder what other bars you should review again though
Oh dear I hope this doesn't open up a massive can of worms for me :D
Anon - Re: Why do you think they added that big tick on the wrapper? What does it indicate?
No Idea - as Alan has pointed out it now says Crispy Wafer :D Perhaps they were trying to reassure me :D
Katie - Re: Perhaps I will email you about reviewing the Cadburys Dream chocolate again
Not a chance :D haha
Ryan - Re: The coffee is always disappointingly weak imo.
I'm totally with you on that one.
Steve ... & EVERYONE - Re: Is it a good or bad thing that I remember the first time around you posted about this lol? Lets say it is a good thing and that im a dedicated readers of your's lol ;)
Of course it is a good thing :D Thanks to everyone for their continued support for the website. It wouldn't be worth doing without your continual input etc. Please continue to read / comment and request :D It's an easy job really :D
Justin - Re: Well done for admitting you were wrong mate. It takes courage to swallow your words and write something again like that.
I wasn't ever 'wrong' I was just misinformed lets say.
Alex - Re: Your comment
You do realise I allow your comments through the spam filter for one reason and one reason only :D entertainment :D Honestly your comments are hilariously misguided. If you genuinely believe any of that you are so so wrong.
Lee - Re: Cappuccino Kit Kats
They are a sad miss aren't they. I wish I had reviewed them at the time they were out.
Matt - Re: It took you long enough to do it lol what was the delay?
I normally decline do re-reviews but I had to oblige in this instance.
Nigel - Re: Liverpool
That is one game I wont be watching. It is all about the ashes tonight.
James - Re: I dont get the people saying it looks like a Kit Kat. More like a blue riband to me
Agreed it is more Blue Riband esc isn't it.
Xenophobe - Re: Swiss or the Canadian version?
Canadian both times.
Phil - Re: Your Comment
I think it would be the equivalent of me giving quite an iconic British bar a really bad review for reasons that aren't justified. There have been a few of them which I hear about from time-to-time :D Thanks for your nice words about my impartiality. I do try my best.
Anne - Re: Your Comment
It wasn't the bar that changed - just the freshness of it!
Ria - Re: Your Comment
I know I know! I could be opening myself up to all sorts here couldn't I :D Like I always say - if you try it be sure to let me know your thoughts. Im always interested to hear your views on matters.
Alan - Re: Your Comment
It does highlight that freshness and production are massivelly important doesn't it. Honestly the difference was really quite profound. I think the 'fuss' was mainly due to it being an iconic Canadian bar, rather like the Kit Kat is here. Good spot on the addition to the wrapper :D Perhaps Nestle read my review and thought they needed to start reassuring people their bars are crispy.
Thanks again everyone - More Christmas products tomorrow I believe. This snow sure is making it feel like Christmas time isn't it. We are still snowed in here in Surrey.
JIM
Post a Comment