Kcal 477 Fat 28.2g Carbs 48.0g (per 100.0g)Over the last week or so I have been sampling a few more variants from the Green & Black's range - some of which have been great, others of which have been not so great. For this very reason I have to admit that Green & Black's isn't one of my favourite brands as it often doesn't live up to it's premium proposition. The G&B price isn't what I would call expensive but at the same time it is more expensive than brands like Dairy Milk or Galaxy who just so happen to be a lot more consistent. Today the bar at hand was this 'Cherry' variant, which came described as 'organic dark chocolate with whole cherries'.
This G&B bar came in the normal 100.0g format that was separated into the tiny sized blocks that I have ranted about way too many times before to go into detail again. The outer wrapper was predominantly coloured with the horrible looking G&B brown colour - one can only hope they will be flipping the placement of the primary and secondary colours soon like they have done on a few other variants from their range. More positively the chocolate itself was covered in a great looking layer of gold G&B branded foil and exhibited a fair amount of chocolaty, fruity smells when broken into. As you can see in the picture above the cherry pieces were generously dispersed throughout the chocolate with most blocks gracing at least one cherry piece.
I can't honestly think of another range where the quality of chocolate swings from one extreme to another quite like G&B's dark chocolate does. Their 70% dark chocolate is absolutely fantastic with its rich, non-bitter cocoa taste that has notes of coffee and red wine. Their 60% dark chocolate (the stuff used here unfortunately!) just so happens to be the polar opposite. The chocolate was just like I had experienced before in that it was fair paced and smooth in melt but utterly lifeless and limp in terms of flavour impact. Where the chocolate was just unexciting the cherry pieces were completely repulsive and the polar opposite of what I was hoping for. The cherries were tart, sour and bitter and frankly tasted like fruit that had past its best before date. Just to cap off a really bad showing for the cherries here they also felt horrible in the mouth and had waxy thick skins that just didn't blend with the melting chocolate in any manner. You can probably guess already that this wasn't a chocolate I consumed in any great quantity. I never like to admit this but over half of it ended up in the bin.
Overall this chocolate has really put me off trying another Green & Black's bar for a long time. It was simply dismal in nearly every which way - from the boring looking packaging (which I have rated way too highly), the bland tasting chocolate and the awful tasting cherries there was no real redeeming feature of this chocolate that I really care to mention. G&B have never managed to blow my socks off with any of their chocolates but there is a certain level of quality that you come to expect when you pay over a certain price point for a chocolate. Unfortunately it is just an all too common experience for me that G&B don't reach the levels that they should be and this bar failed miserably to get anywhere near tolerable standards. I normally try ending my reviews with at least something positive to say about the chocolate bar at hand but I am really struggling with this one. It would be interesting to hear from others who have also tried this Cherry variant as I am wondering if it just wasn't to my own taste or if it really is awful.
4.6 out of 10








18 comments:
Wow, I think this is the first time that I really disagree with you ;) The quality of the chocolate is debatable, I agree, but I really like the sourness of the cherries. I wish they did the cherries with a thin coating of chocolate - I'd buy them any time.
Wow nevermind Green and Blacks dark chocolate being better than their milk chocolate.
Hi Jim,
I'm sorry but I have to disagree with you on this one. I haven't had this chocolate for a few months but I the last time I di have it I loved it. I liked how the cherries were a bit sour but I can see how you could dislike it.
Rxxx
chocolate ending up in the bin is never a good thing. i will have to avoid this, it isn't the sort of chocolate i really go for anyway.
This wouldn't appeal to me overly at the best of times but I'll be steering well clear now - I don't like sour fruits , I guess if you're a fan of those sour fizzy sweets this might appeal lol
This sounds like a realy marmite chocolate. You are either going to love it or hate it. I blooming love cherries so I imagine I would love it.
Daisyx
I totally agree with you on this one. The cherries have a really weird texture, and the flavour does not mesh well with the chocolate at all. :\
I have to disagree, too. The sourness of the cherries is a wonderful contrast to the dark chocolate, and could only be improved by their using their 70 percent dark chocolate instead of the 60 percent. The one thing I'd pick you up on, though, is you saying IN THE REVIEW that you'd given the packaging too high a mark. Well in that case, why didn't you give it the mark you REALLY felt it deserved? Were you trying to prevent the overall mark being "too low" in some sense? I'm baffled why you did this!
When I first saw the title, I thought it sounded great. It made me think of this (Heidi Fruit Cherry - Dark Chocolate with candied sour cherries), which I really like. I like sour cherries, but the "waxy thick skins" part sounds unappealing to me as well.
I disagree with you Jim on this one, but I know some people dislike sour cherries so I can understand where you're coming from. Personally I like sour cherries and think the combo on offer here works well. From what I remember the chocolate was ok, maybe just not as tasty as their 70% recipe. Do G&B do any other dark choc products you haven't tried yet? Also, are you still going to review the caramel one?
Thinking about it this bar reminds me of the Cadbury Black Forest bar you reviewed, except that was far far better!
I wonder if a foray into Orange chocolate is a good idea if this cherry one is anythng to go by lol
I'm not a fan of cherries so I wouldn't ever probably eat this anyway. Cheers for the heads up though Jim lol.
Sorry for the double post but Phil I asked Jim about the caramel flavour the other day and he said that the review would be up on the site soon.
Wow no one is sitting on the fence today! Good stuff :D
Susanne
no two people can agree 100% of the time ;)
The cherries are the deal breaker here and tey just didn't do it for me. Each to their own though! It is always good to hear peoples opinions ... I value them just as much as my own!
David
This one was a 60% recipe though and not their 70% ... why I do not know! Very odd!
Rachel #1
As I said it is great to hear others opinions! This certainly has split perceptions today.
George
Believe me I hate throwing away food ... but this was one I just didn't want to eat anymore of.
Alan
Maybe people who like and are used to cherries would get along much better with these....I also don't like sour fruits!
I personally would still like to see G&B give dark chocolate and orange a try! Who knows what sort of quality it would be ... the rest of their range is all so over the place.
Daisy
I like the Marmite analogy ... it seems very apt for this chocolate.
Rachel #2
It is good to see that not all Rachel's disagree with me :) I also disliked the textures of the cherries.
Paul
I don't quite like the way you have phrased 'pick me up on' ... I don't claim to be a professional reviewer/critic or writer.... hence the dodgy writing style.
In regards to the packaging .. no I don't like this old style wrapper that I photographed here ... but what I did have in mind when reviewing this (8 weeks ago!) was that by the time it made it on the site G&B's would have rolled out their new packaging across the brand which is a hell of alot better than the one displayed ... had I given it a say a 3 or 4 the first thing I would have been 'picked up on' is the fact that it is know different (and a hell of alot better!)
Hope that clears it up for you.
Ana
I might stay clear of cherries for a bit but Susanne might want to check out those cherries you posted! They sound like the thing that she would love!
Phil / Golden
Don't hold me to this but I think I have covered off all their dark chocolate bars now!
Golden is correct about the caramel bar ...as I said the other day that review should be up in the next few weeks .. possibly early January as I have a lot of Christmas reviews to get in before the end of the year.
Thanks for the comments today everyone! Glad you didn't miss this review considering reviews aren't normally posted on a sunday anymore!
JIM
Yup, the cherry variant is ghastly, the sourness of cherry coupled with the mediocre bitterness/tannic taste of the chocolate left me wanting to gag! Indeed, Green and Blacks dark chocolate pales in comparison to other premium brands, lack lustre to put it mildly. Their milk chocolate variants are a little more palatable. I recommend their milk chocolate almond bar; the butter note of the almonds adds a creamy edge to the chocolate. Their praline mini eggs a worth having a stab at if you can purchase them post Easter.
Keep up the fantastic work
No criticism of your writing style intended at all, Jim - it's the love of chocolate and the passion that counts, not the prose style! I was just confused by you saying you'd marked the packaging higher than it deserved, but you've explained why that was now - all clear, thanks! This is a great site, though I suspect it'll have me eating more choc than is good for my waistband! Keep up the great work!
Chris
The almond and hazelnut & raisin flavours are the only ones I haven't tried so I might aswell just finish off my reviews of their range at the start of next year!
Thanks for the suggestions - I will make sure I give you a heads up when I finally egt around to doing them.
Paul
Sorry chap it was proabbly being too defensive. I am glad you see my reasoning for the packaging score now - it is simply just a consequence of me writing these reviews around 6/8 weeks before they appear on the site. Products only really get fast tracked up the queue when they are 'new' to the market as they are the ones that I generally get requested to review.
I hope you continue to enjoy the site. Look at things this way ... you only live once so why not enjoy the things you like! At least if your tastes are similar to my own you will get some sort of idea what chocolates are better than others making it all the more worthwhile :)
Thanks for the comments guy - great hearing from you both.
JIM
I think I'll have to disagree with you, Jim. Like the other members, I liked the tart and sour taste of the cherries, I thought it made for one of their best flavoured chocolates.
Post a Comment