Thursday, 3 December 2009

December 3rd: Green & Black's Caramel

Kcal 511 Fat 27.4g Carbs 56.0g (per 100.0g)

Only a month or so ago I was swearing I wouldn't be buying another Green & Black's product for a 'long time' but having received a request from ChocolateMission reader Phil ages ago I felt obliged to give this bar a well overdue review. I say the review is well overdue for two reasons - firstly I am admittedly not always that keen to review Green & Black's products due to poor past experiences. Secondly this Caramel bar has been almost impossible to track down and it wasn't until I stumbled across it in Waitrose last week that I managed to chance upon it. Described as 'milk chocolate with a soft caramel filling' this was a product that certainly had its work cut out given the quality of the milk chocolate caramel bars I have reviewed previously.

I found this Caramel variant in a 100.0g form that was segregated similarly to the previously reviewed Green & Black's Mint bar. Aesthetically I didn't like the outer wrapper but I guess most of you could have already guessed this so lets not open up that can of worms again. On a more positive note I did like the look of the chocolate with the inner caramel filling looking surprisingly dark and treacle like in colour. In addition to looking relatively appetising the fresh smelling chocolate scents further added promise and managed to engage me a lot more than the packaging at least.

In the interest of not being overly negative I want to get the bad stuff out the way quickly and it wont surprise you to hear that I didn't think all that much about the milk chocolate. Like so many of the Green & Black milk chocolate bars I have had before I just felt that the milk chocolate was lacking in a distinctive taste. There was nothing bad or overly wrong with the milk led, mild cocoa taste but there was just nothing about it that made it stand out as anything special or unique to any other milk chocolates I have had recently. One thing I will say about the chocolate was that the melt was pretty well paced and just about the right thickness for it to accentuate the soft feel of the caramel once it was exposed. On the contrary to the chocolate I have more positive things to say about the caramel as it was noticeably different to any other caramel chocolates I have had recently. The caramel tasted quite like golden syrup but had floral honey notes with a subtle hint of vanilla which I must say did leave a lasting impression on my palette. This was certainly a chocolate best enjoyed once it had been chilled in the fridge but even though this slowed the melt somewhat it was still quite an easy one to consume in 50.0g servings at a time.

Overall Green & Black's were hindered here quite badly by the quality of their milk chocolate as the caramel filling went down pretty well with me. Whether I would say I preferred the caramel filling of this bar over the caramel in Cadbury Caramel or Galaxy Caramel is a separate thing altogether as what makes those bars so wonderful is the way the chocolates and caramels synergise. This could be purely just down to personal opinion and I would welcome your own thoughts on Green & Black's milk chocolate should you wish to share. I have said this many a time over the last year but personally nothing strikes me about the G&B milk chocolate as unique or offering anything different to other products or brands in the market. What really tips the scales for me is the fact that it is at a price premium to brands such as Galaxy, Dairy Milk, Hershey etc who all offer something a little different. To sum up I can't fault the quality of the caramel filling here, but G&B really have to do something with their milk chocolate recipe.

7.8 out of 10

18 comments:

David said...

Jim I thought you weren't going to be buying anymore Green Blacks chocolates after the Cherry flavour incident?

Rachel said...

I expected a better score with all the people saying you should review it for so long.

I have never even seen it? Can you buy it anywhere else other than Waitrose?

Rxxx

Anonymous said...

At least it was a step up from the other G Blacks chocolates you have reviewed lately.

My sister bought a cherry bar on Monday and I refused to try it having seen what you wrote. Surprise surprise she didn't like it.

george said...

dont tell me this has replaced butterscotch. i will never buy green and black again if it has. it is an all time favourite of mine.

Mark said...

Am I the only person thinking that looks nothing like caramel. It looks more like syrup if anything.

Mark said...

Actually whilst I just submitted that I had the thought of why there isn't a mayple syrup chocolate bar out there. Doesen't that sound amazing?

lottie said...

Sorry to be contrary, but I always find the G&B milk chocolate has a pretty distinctive taste. I think of it as a not so sweet but richer chocolate compared to say galaxy/cadbury, and tastes malty to me too. Then again I haven't had it in a long time and also I'm quite mad so I'm probably wrong!
I do like this bar (I enjoy really fluid caramel like that), but yet rarely buy it. Something about G&B just fails to ignite much enthusiasm. Maybe it's the dull packaging, or the constant reiteration of how organic it is, or the high price Idk but it's never my first choice. I think for all the bars it thinks it's better than it actually is, and therefore it's even more disappointing/annoying.

Saying that though, I do have love for their white chocolate :)

Golden_Touch said...

Mark I got addicted to mayple syrup and pancakes last time I was in America. There is nothing tastier than a freshly made batch with melted butter and lashing of syrup.
I am not to sure it would work in a chocolate bar though. I have never seen it tried anyway.

Anonymous said...

I just bought my mum the Green and Blacks small gift set for Christmas and am a bite worried after reading some of your reviews. Have you tried that yet Jim? It is a multi box full of different flavoured chocolates.

Rachel said...

Yum, I quite enjoy G+B's milk chocolate so hopefully I will be able to track this down at some point and give it a try.
It doesn't seem as though the company is releasing any special seasonal flavours this year though. :\

Susanne said...

Mark, maple syrup chocolate has been done before - by Ritter Sport, surprise surprise. It was a limited edition though. I quite enjoyed it and wished the brought it back.

Alan said...

I'm no lover of G&B's milk chocolate either so would probably choose Cadbury or Galaxy or another one over this - I've only ever seen it in those gift boxes of mini bars in the supermarket in the Christmas aisle and my local health food shop lol (it stocks chocolates and such aswell).

I find the G&B milk choc a bit bitter really, a kind of 'generic' taste, how you'd imagine many run of the mill supermarket or non brands to taste although probably better quality and of course -their favourite word-organic and too expensive!.

Steven_F said...

I don't believe it has replaced butterscoth George don't worry. It is just another stand alone flavour that has been around for awhile now.

Jim said...

David

This got a lot of requests so I had to oblige chap. I am a little cross at the lack of quality from G&B at the moment so there isn't anything planned for the next month.

Rachel

I have never seen it anywhere other than Waitrose myself but I haven't exactly been looking out for it.

It is surprisngly illustrious consdering it is such a popular flavour on many other brands.

Anon #1

Well it is good to hear others find the Cherry flavour similarly repulsive.

If I were you though I would have at least given it a try - you can't say you don't like something if you don't know what it tastes like after all!

George

It hasn't chap! Butterscotch is still widely available don't you worry.

Mark

The filling doesen't look like most conventional caramels as it is a bit darker in colour but it tasted like one.

I love your idea of a mayple syrup filled chocolate bar! I am also rather partial to the stuff.

Lottie

We all have different tastes so don't ever apologise for thinking differently please.

Like you I jsut can't get excited by Green & Black's ... no matter how hard I try there is nothing from their range that generates any excitement within me whatsoever ... their Espresso variant is good! That is one of very few I would consider having again.

Golden

A mayple syrup chocolate bar does intrigue me I have to say.

When I was younger we often went to a beach side cafe when we went on holiday in Florid. I swear nothing beats the smell of the freshly cooking pancakes on the griddle ... just perfect with a massive splurge of syrup.

Anon #2

I have tried a lot of the chocolates from that gift pack and can't say I overly impressed myself.

Saying that it does look good ... which is half the issue anyway if we are talking about presents so you could have done far worse :)

Rachel

Good point well made! It is disappointing to see the lack of Christmas limited editions from them this year.

If I remember correctly they were actually pretty good - and there in terms of the flavours involved.

Susanne

Now there is a chocolate I would have loved to have tried. Such a shame I never did.

Alan

I would always choose something Cadbury/Galaxy over the G&B as it has more a definitive taste to it.

This didn't really come close in terms of overall quality when you compare it to the Cadbury Caramel / Galaxy Caramel.

I will have to have a look in my local holland and barrett to see if they sell G&B's ... I think they might do you know!

Steven

Thanks for verifying that!

Thanks everyone! I told you I woudl finally get around to getting this review out :D

JIM

Ana said...

The second picture looks delicious to me. That's exactly how I like caramel chocolate to look.

Chris said...

Hey Jim,

get your hands on some Valrhona Jivara Lait for a real milk chocolate hit. I believe they stock that in waitrose.

Phil said...

Nice to see a review of this :) I must say I haven't had it in a while now but I don't remember much about the milk chocolate, I just remember I liked the caramel. I think it contains cream in the ingredients which makes it that extra bit tasty. I find G&B milk chocolate weird, maybe it's because they use raw sugar rather than refined? (raw sugar has a different taste to refined).

Jim said...

Ana

Thanks for the compliment I try my best with the photos :)

Chris

It sounds nice! I will give it a try/review sometime next year :) Thanks for the recommendation.

Phil

I think you are right about the sugars there chap! I think I did notice it used a different kind on the ingredients list.

Thanks for suggesting I try this bar sorry it took so long for it to feed through.

Thanks for the comments all! More Thorntons I believe up tomorrow.

JIM

 

blogger templates | Make Money Online