Wednesday, 13 January 2010

January 13th: Cadbury Cake Bars Jaffa / Vanilla

Just when I thought it was safe to take my hands off the keyboard and stop writing about cake bar products Cadbury just had to bring out two unannounced limited edition variants didn't they!? Gracing supermarket shelves across the country these 'Jaffa' and 'Vanilla' cake bars are being promoted to hell by Cadbury - I managed to pick these up on a £1 a pack, BOGOF deal ... at 10p a cake bar they might as well be giving them away.

As with the rest of the range these multi packs came in the usual packs of five. As I sometimes do I nabbed a few from each of the packs for myself before leaving the rest of my work office to help themselves to what was left - the only thing to report here was that uptake on the Jaffa flavoured bars was a lot quicker!

In regards to presentation my thoughts were pretty so-so! Both variants looked like I expected with the Jaffa having a orange jelly filling, whilst the vanilla had a fluffy looking white centre. Below are my quick thoughts on each. To save time blabbing on about the quality of the golden sponge in each I think you will be unsurprised to hear that it was of a pretty average quality across both variants, so let me just focus on the fillings!


Cadbury Cake Bar Jaffa:

Kcal 120 Fat 4.9g Fat(sats) 2.8g Carbs 18.4g (per bar)

'Golden sponge with a jaffa flavoured topping' ... sound familiar!? ... 'covered in milk chocolate' ... ok maybe not quite a McVitie's Jaffa Cake bar rip off then!

It may not be a complete like-for-like comparison but I can't help benchmarking this Cadbury Jaffa to it's McVitie's opposite. Truth be told it simply work as well as the McVitie's as the outer milk chocolate was just a little too sweet when combined with the sharp sugary flavours of the orange jelly centre. I am not saying I am a great admirer of the standard of the dark chocolate the lines the McVitie's bar but I have to say it's unsweetened nature works better than the sugary Cadbury milk chocolate did in this bar.

7.0 out of 10



Cadbury Cake Bars Vanilla:

Kcal 155 Fat 8.7g Fat(sats) 4.7g Carbs 17.7g (per bar)

'Golden sponge topped with a vanilla flavour creme, covered with milk chocolate' ... hmm the more I think about this the more I am starting to believe Cadbury released both of these to piss off McVitie's .... MilkyWay Cake Bars anyone!?

These were pretty bad to be honest! They weren't near being inedible but they were probably one of the worst variants of cake bars I have reviewed over the last six months. The outer chocolate was standard Cadbury quality with it's sugary, milky taste but things went awfully down hill from there. The centre had a pretty nasty sweet taste that had an undertone of artificial sweetener bitterness. It had a hint of vanilla to it but I was more distracted by the strange bittersweet concoction of salt, sugar that dominated my tastebuds. It was odd to say the least and it in no way left me wanting to experience it again.

6.1 out of 10

Overall so what have we learnt here!? Well having thought it through it looks to me like Cadbury wanted to throw their weight around by bringing out two flavours of cake bars that are pretty much direct competition for two of McVitie's products ...*slow clap* for Cadbury!! Personally I thought both of these variants were below the standard of others from Cadbury's Cake Bar range such as the Mint, Original and Caramel flavour bars and it was pretty obvious how quickly these had been rushed to market with very little attention paid to the issue of quality. Now I don't even like Bournville dark chocolate ... but here is an idea for you ... Cadbury Cake Bars Jaffa but with Bournville dark chocolate! Any genius could of thought of that! Not only is dark chocolate and orange a better combination but it creates 'new news' for the Bournville brand of Cadbury and stops Cadbury looking so pathetic ripping off their competition so indiscreetly!! Readers thoughts are most welcome ...

16 comments:

Claudia said...

Nothing will ever be as good as a Jaffa Cake bar :P Especially not rubbish imitations ;)

I love vanilla, but not when it's more sweet than vanilla flavoured. It doesnt sound good :(

David said...

what on earth are cadburys doing trying to make jaffa cakes? How shameful.

Steven_F said...

It is annoying they couldn't have a better go at the vanilla flavour as that actually tickled my fancy. They should seriously start taking more thought with some of the things they bring to market.

Rachel said...

Am I the only one that think the cross picture of the vanilla looks really nice :)

I bet they used a lot of sweetners in these Jim which is why you are probably sensing them in the taste.

Rxxx

Emma said...

This is so wrong of Cadburys to do. The supermarket jaffa cake rips offs are fine but bigger companies completely ripping off an idea is just not right. They should hand their heads in shame.

george said...

well there is a thing. cadbury being totaly unoriginal. it isn't like we haven't seen this before now.

Anonymous said...

Have you any idea where I could buy some of these? I know you don't rate them highly but I would still like to try them myself.

Thank You

Imran

emma said...

i think the vanilla one was absolutly terrible and i agree there was a distusting after taste ... the vanilla flavour not lasting long. i prefer the fudge one 10x more.

Alan said...

I've had both of these and while I really hated the vanilla (not my favourite flavour at the best of times)I really like the Jaffa ones. I preferred them to the McVities ones and found the the change to the thick milk chocolate a preference over the weedy thin dark covering of the McVities :) It is true that a Bournville covering would have been an obvious match but still I was rather taken with these :)

David said...

@anonymous(imran) I would say your best bet is going to be pound shops. This look destined for the bargain bins if jim's review is anything to go by.

Emma said...

I tried the vanilla flavour about a month ago and thought they were absolutely wrank. I left the rest for my brother and even he didn't like them.

Mark said...

It is not like you to get nasty about a product in your conclusions. Cadburys might have copied Mcvities but it is business after all.

Phil said...

Personally, I'm fed-up with the endless varieties of cake bars that Cadbury bring out. There's always a new one, always changing their labeling, it gets too confusing. And I agree with Jim, copying off McVities isn't right.

Susanne said...

Totally agree with you about the vanilla one (haven't tried the jaffa variant, doesn't appeal to me at all). Pretty horrid stuff! Tough competition anyway as the Milky Way bar is quite good, but I'm pleased this is only a limited version.

Ana said...

The Jaffa Cake one actually looks more tempting to me than the McVitie's version. The outer chocolate layer seems thicker and so does the orange jelly layer above the sponge. But I also believe dark chocolate works better with orange.

Jim said...

Claudia

I personally think you are right - nothing willl surely beat the Jaffa Cake at its own game.

I too love vanilla so as you can tell I was really disappointed myself.

David

It isn't the cleverist thing they have ever done is it.

Steven

I would have loved the vanilla one to be good but it just wasn't to be I guess. Innovation rather than imitation lets hope the future brings.

Rachel

No not at all - it looked alright but just tasted rubbish :D

Emma

Indeed shame on Cadbury for these! They are poor imitation products.

Imran

I got mine in Sainsburys but I havent seen them for weeks. I think they might already be out of distribution.

Emma

Ahhh come on the mint or caramel ones have to be the best :D check out my previous reviews for what I think about the Fudge ones :)

Alan

Well as I say mate we all have different tastes. One thing I would agree with you about is the thickness of the chocolate which is certainly far thicker than the McVities.

David

Good thinking you could be right about the £1 shops.

Emma

3 Emmas!??? Blimey what is going on haha! If both you and your brother didn't like them did you just throw them out!? I wouldn't be surprised.

Mark

I wasn't nasty - more forthright in my views :)

Phil

I have said this before and think your bang on! They really should just focus more on their core chocolate range ... it is getting frustrating isn't it.

Susanne

Yeh the Milky Way is definitely the better out of the two. Phew I was hoping there wasn't going to be a load of people saying I was wrong about the vanilla ones ... seemingly everyone hated them as much as I did :)

Ana

Yep they certainly should have used dark chocolate. It combines with orange far more than milk chocolate does. Oh well live and learn I guess!

Thanks everyone - shame these both suck so much.

JIM

 

blogger templates | Make Money Online