Friday, 19 February 2010

February 19th: Guylian Opus Collection

Following my reviewing of the disappointing Guylian Trufflina selection box the other day I bring you the second of the two chocolate collections I got in that wonderful 2 for £4 deal in my local OneStop.

The Guylian Opus collection came described as an assortment of the finest Belgian chocolates and contained 8 different truffle pieces which were all portioned twice. Looking at the outer box just like the Trufflina selection the presentation was absolutely fantastic with the box cutting clean, sophisticated look making good use of the gold fonts and clear branding. Inside as you will see below most of the chocolates looked utterly fantastic and looked wonderfully crafted.

Below are my brief thoughts on each of the eight pieces (working from left to right in each picture) - ratings are from Very Poor to Superb.


Massenet - Unfortunately this piece was rather like the Trufflina chocolates I reviewed last week and had a really disappointing filling. The outer white chocolate substantiated a fine set of vanilla hint cream flavours however the inner milk chocolate mousse filling was dull and lacklustre in flavour. Poor.

Beethoven - This was a superb looking chocolate and was one that I was really looking forward to trying once I had read the billing of 'creme cappuccino cream'. What I liked about this piece was that the top layer of white chocolate could be bitten off and eaten before tucking into the milk chocolate constituents below. Disappointingly the inner filling was lacking in coffee flavours a little though the it did display a really fine soft texture that contrasted nicely with the crisp outer shell. Good.

Mozart - This was beyond doubt my favourite in the box. This chocolate not only looked great but it tasted like a dream! This chocolate encompassed an outer shell of white and milk chocolate filled with coffee hazelnut praline and a single whole hazelnut piece. The outer chocolate was wonderful and melted perfectly into an inner nutty hazelnut paste that was wonderfully complimented by a note of coffee. The taste was wonderfully capped off by the hazelnut which reaffirmed the woody flavour of the praline and delivered a wonderful crunch. Superb.

Gounod - If you have ever tasted the standard Guylain Seashell chocolates you would be very familiar with the taste here. Under the gold foil wrapper this piece combined a thick outer shell of milk chocolate with a wonderfully tasty hazelnut praline that sat below. It was a little no thrills and not on the adventurous side but you can hardly blame Guylian for sticking their classical recipe in the box at least once. Very Good.

Bach - On the back of the box this piece was described as Gianduja so I was really looking forward to seeing what sort of quality it could deliver. Unfortunately I have to say I was a little underwhelmed as it didn't quite offer the total Gianduja experience. To sum this piece up simply it tasted no different to the Gounod chocolate above but had a slightly smoother less gritty texture. Although this was fair it didn't have the melt in the mouth Gianduja qualities I have experienced before - I was left disappointed. Standard.


Donizetti - Once again this chocolate varied very little from Gounod in that it contained the same hazelnut praline filling, however had a disc of dark chocolate placed on top. To be honest the dark chocolate only tasted a little bit stronger than the milk chocolate that sat below, thus it tasted only a little different to the Gounod. Again this wasn't such a bad thing but it was a little disappointing to see little differentiation. Standard.

Puccini - Look at the marbled effect on the butterflies ... don't they look awesome!? When I had finally stopped admiring the craft work that had gone into these I eventually got around to trying the orange flavoured creme chocolates. Much like I found with the rest of the selection there was nothing wrong with the outer chocolate at all - it was creamy and packing a chocolate flavour hit. Unfortunately like many of the other pieces it was the inner creme that didn't deliver with the orange flavours not featuring enough in the overall taste. The fruit element was weakly implemented and didn't cut through the chocolate flavours making for another underwhelming piece. Poor.

Verdi - This final chocolate came billed as having 'smooth truffle filling' ... right just like the other half of the box then! Apologies for repeating myself but this was again yet another that had fine tasting outer milk chocolate but when it came to the cut and thrust of the inner truffle filling it was undoubtedly disappointing. Indeed the taste was smooth but it lacklustre in terms of flavours. Poor.


Overall whilst these offered a little more than the tedious Trufflina box this Opus collection didn't exactly sparkle. What is really frustrating with this assortment was that all of the outer chocolate constituents were really tasty - it was just some of the fillings were lacklustre in flavour and way too many of them tasted too similar. If you look at what I say about the Verdi, Bach, Donzinetti, Massenet pieces you will see that the story is pretty much the same for all four, and simply this just wasn't good enough for me. This is a bit of a shame as there are some real stars in this collection - the Mozart and Gounod especially stood out as high quality chocolates. Unfortunately for Guylian it is hardly like I can go recommending a chocolate selection box based on the fact I thought 25% were better than average. One thing I can say is that Guylian did well with the presentation and the collection had some real stand out chocolates. As well as they did in those areas, when it came to the taste test Guylian again came up a little short and didn't quite live up to expectations.

7.1 out of 10

17 comments:

Ana said...

For me this was a case of it looks a lot better than it actually tastes. There wasn't a single one that made me go "wow, this is really good!" Yes, the chocolate melts nicely in the mouth. Actually, no, it would have melted nicely if I had liked the taste enough to just let it melt and not chew it fast... just to get over it.

I thought the Puccini was the nicest of them all and that the Mozart was the worst, though. The white chocolate one tasted like... almost nothing? Well, at least it didn't taste bad.

Overall, a big, big disappointment considering that the looks of the box and of the chocolates themselves promised so much :( And normally they cost a lot... I think it would be a little more than 7 pounds in your currency. OK, so I got them for a third of the price, they were on sale, but I was still disappointed. No, I am not having these again, except maybe the orange flavoured one. But please, Guylian, make it more intense.

I wonder if anyone can tell I was really excited about trying these and they really let me down :(

Golden_Touch said...

Far from amazing but they look better than the trufflina things you wrote about the other day.

Rachel said...

I see the Guylian heart pralines have made another sneaky appearance under the radar. It is good to see you are consistent with your reviewing Jim :D as you rated them pretty well here also.

Rxxx

Steven_F said...

It was only about half way down that I realised all the names were composers lol epic stupidity on my part. The Pucini looks so well made they do that marble effect the best.

Tony-C said...

These still have the same problem as the other ones as they just as horrendously expensive. I think they were £6 last time I saw them.

David said...

The mozart does sound incredible. They should just do a box of them on their own.

george said...

like I said the other day just stick to the praline seashells with guylian you can't go wrong.

Alan said...

these look fantatsicbut seemt o suffer the same problems as the truffle box. Guylian have never been a particular favourite of mine to be honest, I find the seashells a little boring and the fillings a bit too smooth..runny even and a touch monotonous. They do look wonderful though!

Anonymous said...

Some of these look terrifically crafted it is shame they aren't more varied in taste.

Nick said...

I am a little surprised to see that these are still around. I got given a box of them what seems like years ago now.

I would agree with you that some of the chocolates look great but I was similarly annoyed that most of them tasted the same.

Lauren said...

Yay as I predicted the other day you did like them a little better. great review.

Duncan said...

I would give these away as gift based on the sole reason that they look expensive. That is half of what giving a gift is all about.

Kieran said...

The beethoven looks a beast as does the Donizetti. Although you haven't rated this highly I would still love to give this a try.

Chris said...

I thought this collection would score far higher than the seven ou have given it Jim.

We had a box open in our house over Christmas after they were gifted to my mum and they were all eaten within a day. I don't remember one standing from the rest but perhaps that is because like you say they all taste the same lol.

Maybe I am just being biased because I am a bit of fanboy when it comes to Guylian praline.

Phil said...

I've had these and come to a similar conclusion as you Jim. I thought they were all just OK, not horrible but not amazing either. They are certainly better than the last Thorntons boxed chocolates I had anyway. I liked the orange one the best.

Tom said...

These looks awesome I might pick up some to enjoy with my wife tonight with a bottle of wine tonight. Husband of the year award is surely in bound.

Jim said...

Ana

I think you are right about it looking a bit better than it actually tastes but at leas they put the effort in there I guess.
I can't belive you didn't like the Mozart - I loved that one.

I am sorry you felt let down by this one. Console yourself with some other Guylian product :D

Golden

Yeh these were far better than the Trufflina.

Rachel

Phew I am glad I was consistent there. I reviewed these weeks apart so it is could to see.

Steven

It is a Friday don't worry you are allowed to be a little slower tan usual.

Tony

£6 is too much for me for these. You can get an even nice box of chocolates for that price.

David

You and me both I tought it was very good.

George

I think this is probably good adivice with Guylian.

Alan

I have never had a Guylain seashell that has been runny in the middle? I find the centres quite dry if anything .. how odd?

Anon

Yeh that is bang on. They should have varied up the flavours a little more and taken as much care with the flavours aswell as the crafting.

Nick

Ten years ago!? They can't possibly of been around that long surely. I am glad to see that I wasn't the only one that thought these could have been a bit more varied flavourwise.

Lauren

Well done :D can you predict Saturdays lottery results now please haha.

Duncan

True true! I would never give a tatty looking box of chocolates way no matter how good I thought they tasted.

They have to look good aswell as taste good. Like you say it is almost half the deal.

Kieran

If you do give it a go let me know what you think.

Chris

You kids do keep me up to date with the latest lingo ... Fanboy :D I like it.

I can imagine that these would be eaten pretty quickly in my family house also. We all love praline chocolates.

Phil

It is funny you should mention Throntons boxed chocolates they sent me another new box today to try. I guess they still like me afterall.

Tom

Have a nice weekend. I am sure that will win you some good man points with your partner.

Thanks everyone - glad you enjoyed the review today.

JIM

 

blogger templates | Make Money Online