Wednesday, 14 April 2010

April 14th: Cadbury Dream / Bournville Fingers

As I am sure you are all well aware, one of my favourite everyday milk chocolates is Cadbury Dairy Milk. If you are a regular visitor to the site you may also know that my love for Cadbury UK begins and ends with their milk chocolate - my reviews of the Cadbury Dream and Cadbury Bournville are evidence that I really don't think all that much about their capabilities in the arts of white and dark chocolate.

Despite me having previously poor experiences with the Dream and Bournville sub-brands, I couldn't help myself when I saw these Cadbury Dream & Bournville Fingers, as it was my turn to bring some biscuits into my work office this week. On the packaging both the boxes claim these are new, though anyone with any common sense will know that they are just the old dark and white fingers rebranded.

As I said above I bought these 125.0g packs to bring in to work, and co-workers were more than happy to share their views.


Cadbury Dream Fingers


Kcal 120 Fat 6.0g Fat(sats) 3.2g Carbs 12.8g (per 4 fingers)

'Crisp biscuits covered with white chocolate'.

Had you asked me which of the two I was least looking forward to trying, these Dream Fingers would have been my answer. In my opinion Cadbury's Dream white chocolate is god awful - it is a sugary, bland substance that I'm not even sure deserves to be called chocolate. Now having said all that I quickly have to retract it all, as to my own surprise I actually really liked these. The outer chocolate wasn't great, but it benefited massively from being so thinly implemented. The taste generated was sweet and sugary, but it had a nice milkiness and allowed the crisp, buttery flavours of the shortbread biscuit centres to shine through. I didn't think they were incredibly satisfying, but they had a real moreishness about them and were nice to eat in small amounts with a coffee.

7.9 out of 10



Cadbury Bournville Fingers

Kcal 100 Fat 5.6g Fat(sats) 3.2g Carbs 12.4g (per 4 fingers)

'Crisp biscuit covered in dark chocolate'

The words Cadbury Bournville always send a shiver down my spine. Not everyone will agree with me, but I think the Bournville chocolate we get here in the UK really isn't that good - the only Bournville bar I have ever liked was actually produced in France (See HERE). Still I was hoping that like the Dream Fingers, these Bournville Fingers would prove to be better than the original chocolate. Getting straight to the matter, I did enjoy these Fingers more so than a standard Bournville bar, but the quality of the chocolate still hampered the overall product. The outer chocolate was devoid of real flavour and just generated a meagre offering of musty, unsweetened cocoa flavours with it's waxy and laboured melt. The biscuit element still produced the goods, however it was general consensus that they weren't as good as either normal milk chocolate or Dream Fingers.

6.6 out of 10



Overall I was half expecting to write a review saying how I didn't like either of these two offerings, but the Dream Fingers pulled it out the bag and proved themselves to be far superior product to the original Cadbury Dream bar. The office environment always offers a great opportunity to test if one product is superior to another, and this comes mainly from the ability to observe 'which gets finished first'. Well judging by the fact the Dream Fingers box was finished at the time the Bournville Fingers box was still half full, it gives you some idea which one was preferred. Out of the two I would definitely buy the Dream Fingers again, but the Bournville Fingers probably not.

Have any of you tried either of these yet? Which did you prefer?

26 comments:

Daisy said...

Nom nom nom nom. I love white fingers, they are the ultimate party food.

Dx

Rachel said...

Yes I agree the white chocolate fingers are the nicest ones you can get.

I don't know what it is about bournville but I really don't like it. It just seems really old fashioned and I can name about ten other dark chocolates that are better.

Rxxx

Anonymous said...

Have you seen the double dipped chocolate fingers? I haven't tried them yet but they look nice.

David said...

I can't think of fingers without thinking about kids parties. They are cult classic for them aren't they?

jelly, Finger biscuits, party rings and sausage rolls lol ahh the memories.

Nick said...

I think it is good to see Cadbury try and make more of both Dream and Bournville. I have always thought they were the forgotten parts of Cadbury and that they focus too much on just milk chocolate. I do agree they could be a lot better tasting than they are though. The last time I had a dream bar it made my teeth hurt it was so sugary.

Claudia said...

They look addictive. Nom nom nom indeed :P

george said...

hi jim sorry i have not been around for a long time my pc broke. i have a lot of catching up to do lol. i normally just buy milk chocolate fingers whenever i have them. i can't be dealing with cadburys other chocolates.

John said...

We always have packs and packs of these in our tea room. The dark chocolate fingers normally get left well alone and they normally go past their sell by date. The milk chocolate ones get gobbled up in seconds.

Anonymous said...

I am obsessed with Cadbury Fingers at the momment. I can eat my way through one of those big bags you can now get in about ten minutes. Once I open the packet I just can't help myself.

Rachel said...

When I saw Bournville I instantly thought "oh no, this isn't going to be a positive review" but it's surprising to hear these biscuit Fingers were somewhat tasty.
This part made me chuckle though: "The outer chocolate wasn't great, but it benefited massively from being so thinly implemented." You mean, the best thing about the chocolate was that there wasn't a lot of it? Heh heh, I think I will give these a miss. :P

Alan said...

It's cool too see your reveiw of these up Jim, I was wondering what you'd think - I'm surprised at the Dream ones, I honestly thought they'd be horrible lol. I'm not the biggest fan of Fingers but it's nice too see a few varieties. I like Bournville so I'd prob like those, but I think I might try these Dream ones :)

As David says they are the ultimate kids party food aren't they lol I can't remember a birthday party either as a kid that didn't have them on the table along with the jelly, icecream, Wotsits, Fox's party rings etc(theyve reduced them to just a few colours now!) and usually my aunts cakes lol I wonder what today's kids party tables look like :S I heard they costa fortune!

Richard said...

I thought you were going to trash these Jim :-) I knew before you didn't think much of dream or bournville chocolate so I was certainly surprised to see you actually enjoyed them.

Nick said...

You guys are all forgetting the ultimate party food that is blamange. You can't forget ice cream either.

After read this review this morning I bought some Cadbury Fingers on the way too work. I am eating them with my tea right now :>

Phil said...

They have done white chocolate Fingers for years, does anyone know if these taste much different? I've always been fond of them but they are very sweet. I find that the dark ones are improved greatly if they're dunked in tea or coffee. They used to do the dark Fingers in mint and orange flavours around Christmas time.

Phil said...

One thing I always noticed about the dark ones is that they always seem to look 'scuffed' and dusty, which isn't exactly appetizing!

Katie said...

Cadburys fingers are something i could eat all day long given half a chance. They have the pringles effect that is for sure.

I would rank them (best to worst) milk, white and then the dark. I am yet to try the double choc ones.

Duncan said...

I got a bit of a soft spot for fingers. My grandma used to always lay them out when we went around for tea.

You can get them really cheap nowadays. I think they are about £1 a box.

Mysterio_6_19 said...

Cadbury Fingers FTW. Nothing beats a bucket load of fingers and a warm mug of tea. Gaaaaaaawgeous.

Susanne said...

I quite like the white ones, although the only time I tried the Dream bar I hated it.
Never had the Bournville ones and won't bother - totally agree that Bournville is best left untouched.

Katie said...

I have to add my two pennies worth to this review.

The best fingers by far are the dark chocolate ones. I love dipping them in hot chocolate and then licking off all the chocolate. The dipping bit is a fine art, if you leave them in the hot chocolate too long they break off and you get grotty soggy bits in your hot chocolate.

I love fingers :)

Paul said...

You are too hard on Bournville Jim. I think it has been vastly improved from what it used to be.

Lauren said...

Whilst we are on the topic of party food, you can't have a decent party without battenburg cakes and ice cream. Those were the days weren't they.

I have never been that fond of fingers myself. I think there are nicer biscuits.

Thea said...

I'm also catching up on the site since Easter...the photography in this review is especially great. Let me get this straight now...in the UK do people habitually actually gift each other chocolate on Easter?? If so that is brilliant...in the US as far as I'm aware it is only children who receive Easter baskets when they wake up, and everyone else has to shop for themselves!

Jim said...

PART 1

Daisy

Your nom nom brought a smile to my face! Very funny! You can't have a kids party without Cadbury Fingers.

Rachel

I am not a fan of Bournville either. It surprises me that such an established chocolate brand is so poor at making dark chocolate.

Anon

I have done but I haven't reviewed them yet. I will get something up soon. I might aswell complete the set after all.

David

God your list of party food brought back the memories. You forgot cocktail sausages though :D

Claudia

Where has everyone got this nom nom thing from? :D

Nick

Yeh the Dream bar is horrendously sugary. As I said above it puzzles me why Cadbury's dark and white chocolates are so poor when their milk chocolate is so good!? One of lifes mysteries I guess :D

George

No problem - good to see you are back. Still not got a keybaord with a caps lock I see haha :D The milk chocolate ones are the most classic out of the lot aren't they.

John

We always seems to have some knocking around the office aswell. We literally start drowning in the little beggers when Christmas time comes around. I have no idea why they boom so much at Christmas. It is a bit puzzling when you think about it.

Anon

Man those pouches are pretty big aren't they :D That is a lot of Cadbury fingers.

Rachel

To be honest I wasn't expecting to like these much but they did surprise me.

I see what you mean about what I wrote :D I guess the point I was trying to get across was that in small amounts it is passable as what chocolate ... it is just when you get quite a concentrated amount (i.e. a full block of it!!), that it becomes too much, and too sugary. That is for me anyway.

Alan

I haven't had many of those foods listed above for years. I didn't even know party rings still existed :D Stuff on legends those things.

I would be interested to hear your views on the Bournville ones. I know you quite like the stuff! Wait until they are on deal chap!

Richard

You and me both! As I said in the review the Bournville ones weren't my favourite but they were certainly passable as far as biscuits go.

Phil

I have no idea chap. All I saw was the new Dream and Bournville branding so I thought I would give them a whirl! Like you say it would be great to hear from anyone who knew what they tasted like before they got rebranded.

I had no idea they did so many different flavours. Like you have mentioned they seem very popular around Christmas time. I do wonder why that is! It is a bit random!

I think they look scuffed most the time because they come loose in the plastic tray. You are right they don't look good.

Nick

Blancmange and Angel Delight ... now we don't get anymore old school than that :D

Katie

The pringles effect being 'once you pop you can't stop??' :D now there was a successful marketing campaign!

Duncan

They are quite an old product so I am not surprised to hear your grandma was a fan. I think a lot of people on here like eating these with tea.

Mysterio

Haha you just gave me good evidence for the above.

Susanne

As I said to rachel above I think the white ones are bearable because the Dream chocolate is in a good proportion to the biscuit. I don't blame you for leaving the Bournville alone.

Jim said...

PART 2

Katie

That is a very detailed approach to your method of eating these. I personally think they would be nice broken into yogurt or ice cream! I imagine they are in hot chocolate.

Paul

Really? All the times I have had it, I don't think it has changed all that much!? What does everyone else think?

Lauren

I would agree that there are nice biscuits. In fact I have a pretty long list of biscuits that are better.

I was never a fan of battenburg cake myself. If we are talking about coffee and walnut cake that is a different matter altogether :D

Thea

Thanks for the nice words about the photos.

Indeed most people do gift chocolate to each other at Easter. Mostly to kids obviosuly, but partners also exchange gifts most the time.

I did buy for my family this year - it is really down to personal circumstances. It isn't quite like Christmas where EVERYONE buys each other presents. It is a bit more lassiez faire!!!

Thanks everyone - yet another product review from the UK! I am on fire :D

JIM

Alan said...

Bournville tastes no different to me as it always has done lol

Yeah Party Rings are still going strong, as is Angel Delight and Instant whip! In fact we've got 3 packets of Angel Delight in the cupboard! lol

 

blogger templates | Make Money Online