Friday, 20 August 2010

August 20th: Mr Tom Chocolate

Kcal ??? Fat ??? Fat(sats) ??? Carbs ???

Before I kick off this review I must first take the time to thank my friends over at Candyholic.com for making this post possible. My pal Kristian from Candyholic was recently kind enough to send me a parcel containing some of the newest products out in Germany. Included in the package was some of the latest Milka and Lindt bars that you will no doubt see appearing on the site in the coming weeks. Kristian also happen to include some of his own favourite chocolates, including this Mr Tom Chocolate bar. Here in the UK the original Mr Tom bar can be found in most newsagents and supermarkets, however I have never seen this chocolate variety before. On the packaging this bar came described as 'milk chocolate with caramelized and roasted peanuts' and was of course produced in Germany.

This chocolate came in the slightly odd sized 150.0g and came in a square bar format not unlike a Ritter Sport chocolate. The wrapper wasn't totally reminiscent of the crazy retro looking Mr Tom bars we get in the UK, but it looked fine nonetheless and the chocolate looked reasonably appetising with visible chunks of peanuts distributed throughout. One slight annoyance for me was that despite the wrapper being similar in style to Ritter chocolates it wasn't resealable, which obviously wasn't ideal for a bar of its size. As I ate the bar over the course of a few days, it seemed to lose it's freshness a little, that said the wafts of peanut smells I got when I opened the thing for the first time were extremely tempting.

Judging by the aromas and the sheer volume of peanuts dispersed throughout, I was expecting a very nutty tasting chocolate and this is exactly what I got. Starting with the quality of the chocolate it has to be said it wasn't the best I have ever tasted, though neither was it the worst. On the back of the wrapper the ingredients stated that the chocolate comprised of 30% cocoa solids which I guess is around the expected strength for the average mass produced milk chocolate. In terms of taste it was nothing out of the ordinary with the flavour base centered around sweet milk and mild cocoa influences. To be honest it didn't really have any compelling or unique features about it, and was more just a bog standard milk chocolate that wouldn't have seemed out of place in any Nestle or Mars produced mass confection. The peanut pieces placed throughout the chocolate were portioned pretty generously, though as I so often find their chopped nature came to their detriment as they failed to have the same sort of cut through in taste as I'm sure whole nuts would have. Don't get me wrong, the caramel and salty influences were still there in force, however they didn't create the lasting impression that other peanut flavoured chocolates have done in the past.

Overall this was a decent enough milk chocolate that had it's strong points, but I ultimately felt like it could have been done a little better than what I experienced here. On the rare occasion that I do indulge in a Mr Tom bar, one of the things that I always love about it is how the peanuts are implemented in their natural whole state as it gives the bar not only a unique and compelling look, but also a raw and very 'in your face' peanut flavour experience. In this Mr Tom Chocolate bar the peanut element was somewhat masked by a no better than average milk chocolate, which leads me to be the question why didn't they just use the base of an original Mr Tom and then just coat it in milk chocolate!? Casting my mind to better alternatives I would say the Whittaker's Original Peanut Block is the best example of a bar that does this combination the best. In light of that I would recommend you give that bar a try before this Mr Tom Chocolate.

7.3 out of 10

27 comments:

SilentAngel said...

I love the regular Mr.Tom bar so i think i have to try this one :)

frannie84 said...

I love crunchy chocolate, and although I don't care much about nuts, I do usually love chocolate with nuts in it (though almonds, macadamias, pecans and walnuts are my favorites). I definitely am picky about the quality of chocolate since I'm used to the stuff you get in Europe, but unless it's really cheap stuff, the chocolate is usually good enough. And now I have to go eat a chocolate peanut cluster.

David said...

Yum I love the normal Mr Tom bars. I have always thought that they were crying out for a dose of chocolate.

It's a shame we have never seen someone like Hotel Chocolat try something similar.

Alex said...

The normal Mr Tom wrappers are the worst. They look like they were designed in the 80s and no one has bothered to change then since.

You would have thought someone who works for that company would have bothered to modernise them sometime.

Kim said...

I can never find Mr Tom bars anymore. Tesco used to sell but they stopped doing so like a year ago.

The only place I can find them now is random news stands on my way in to work (I work in London). They are my only option if I fancy a Mr Tom.

Golden_Touch said...

Personally I wouldn't ever buy this. Although it seems well different from the normal Mr Tom bar I'm still put off by the fact it is branded Mr Tom in the first place. I remember trying the normal one ages ago and throwing it away because it was so bland.

Duncan said...

This wasn't what I was imagining when I saw the title at all. Why do you think they changed the structure of their product?

Peanuts are the strength of what they do. I don't understand they they would make them the secondary added bit and make the chocolate the main base. It would have made far more sense to have a base of peanuts and then put chocolate on top.

Nigel said...

Lol just looked at that Whittakers chocolate you have linked at the bottom. That has an insane amount of peanuts in lol. It sort of shows this bar up for it's failings.

Paul said...

I'm undecided about Mr Tom bars. I have eaten them sometimes and they have been really tasty and full of flavour, but other times I have had them they have been really bland.
It must be to do with the freshness and how old they are because the time they have been nice the nuts have always been crunchy.

Steven_F said...

Great review Jim. I'm not a massive lover of peanuts so I don't think I would buy this one for myself.

My sister goes gaga goo goo for peanut brittle though, I always buy her the stuff from Thorntons when it is her birthday. If I ever see this I might buy her a bar.

Anonymous said...

MR TOM BARS ARE THE BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Justin said...

Yeah I can imagine the chocolate not being the best quality ever. I can't think of a product that Hosta make which is renowned for it's chocolate prestige. Thanks for the review Jim, it's brill seeing all the stuff they have abroad.

Rachel said...

I don't think I like peanuts enough to endure this one. If you don't like peanuts then it's hardly like there is much there for you lol. Can you remember what % of the bar was made up of nuts? I remember you saying that the whittakers bar Nigel is gushing over had something insane like 25% peanuts in it. This looks like it could be rivalling it.

Rxxx

Estelle said...

I know I have said this millions and millions of times but how and why does Germany have so many different products that we don't have?
It must be the junk food capital of the world :) I swear over half your reviews start with '..... this product which I got from Germany'.

If I lived there I think I would spend all my money on chocolate lol.

Dx

Anonymous said...

Did you know you can buy this here http://www.confectionaffection.net/mr-tom-chocolate--peanut-bar-150g-2511-p.asp

David said...

@Alex I think the wrapper is made to look old on purporse. I think it's supposed to be retro.

Andrew said...

I've seen this on sale in my local market but I wouldn't ever buy it from there cause it just seems a bit dodge.

If I was to see it in a shop I might buy it but probably not now I have seen this review. It doesn't sound worthy of my cash :)

Martin said...

The only place I can buy normal mr toms are from ebay now. Every once and awhile I buy in a massive stockpile of them to keep me going for a few weeks. I can't believe it is such an unloved brand :( It is one of our oldest ones we should look after it more.

Richard said...

Thats not a Mr Tom bar at all. Why have they changed it so much from their original bar?

"In this Mr Tom Chocolate bar the peanut element was somewhat masked by a no better than average milk chocolate, which leads me to be the question why didn't they just use the base of an original Mr Tom and then just coat it in milk chocolate!?"

You tell me Jim! You tell me!!!!!!

Lauren said...

I wouldn't like this because I don't like peanuts :) I don't think the chocolate is going to do anything to change my mind is it :)

Mysterio916 said...

My dad loves Mr Toms but I don't understand them at all. All they are like peanuts and hard syrup, you got to be careful not to break your teeth on them lol. Thanks for the review but I think I will pass.

Phil said...

I'm surprised this didn't score better, as the idea sounded great. I don't think I've ever tried those Mr Tom bars as I never liked the sound of them. But a chocolate and peanut bar sounds more tempting. The Whittakers one certainly sounds much better.

Alan said...

I've never actually eaten a Mr Tom bar before, i very rarely see them and they just pass me by when I do lol

@ Alex - as David says, i think the idea is that it looks retro, much like many US chocolate wrappers do really!

Ali said...

They shouldn't have changed tact from what they usually make because it seems like they came acroper here.

If it's not broke, don't fix it.

Its an old saying but its very rarely disproved.

Mysterio916 said...

Mr Tom's FTW!!!!!! I haven't had one for ages. I better they are all the better for having a dose of chocolates on them.

Jim said...

Part 1

Frazni

Well you have no excuses since you live in Germany :D If you try it let me know what you think.

Frannie

Haha if it is top quality chocolate you are after I don't think you should look in the direction of this bar. It isn't the best for milk chocolate.

David

Hotel Chocolat do make Peanut Butter Brittle. I haven't tried it yet, but it looks like it is criminally lacking in any chocolate. It seems a bizarre admission given it is their strength.

Alex

I think it is a very concious decision not to change it chap. I think they are going for the whole retro feel with this brand. I think it looks pretty cool myself.

Kim

I think Waitrose sell them!? Apart from that you are right I only ever tend to see them on sale in smaller retailers.

Golden

Bland!? If you think the Mr Tom is bland you need to make sure you avoid the Hershey Payday! Trust me it is absolutely awful. I think it scored one of the lowest scores ever on ChocolateMission.

Duncan

I have no idea why they changed it around. Like I said in my concluding paragraph all they need to do was set the chocolate on top of the peanut fused base and it would have been all dandy. It was poor thinking swapping it all around.

Nigel

Yeah the Whittakers bar is a great example of how this should have been done. The 25% nuts was plentiful alright :D

Paul

It probably depends on how old the two bars were. I'm sure you will probably find that the crunchier of the two was made with fresher produce. Nuts are one of those things which can really vary in quality from batch to batch. Quality control must be pretty hard for Hosta.

Steven

It sounds like your sister is similar to my mother. She loves peanut butter brittle as well. I don't think she has tried the Thorntons stuff but I will be giving her some of the HC PB brittle in the next few days so I will let you know what it is like.

Anon

It seems like we have found a fan.

Jim said...

Part 2

Justin

Hey I wont take any Hosta bashing! They make the mighty Romy Classic Cocos! That is my favourite coconut chocolate ever. I absolutely love it. Their chocolate isn't the best but they do make some wonderful chocolates.

Rachel

I have no idea what the peanut % was in this one but I doubt it will be up there with the Whittakers chocolate. If you have the option between the two I would strongly suggest you go with the Whittakers option.

Estelle

Estelle that is a question I can't answer I'm afraid! I would think it is largely down to the type of consumer they cater for. I most people here in the UK probably have a small range of bars that they know and like and are comfortable just rotating their consumption around them (which is no bad thing at all!!). I think abroad (especially Germany!) people might be a little more adventurous, thus the manufactures feeling the need to constantly refresh their ranges and provide new flavours. I could be totally wrong .... I will pose that very question to the masses in an upcoming 7Days of Chocolate Reviews.

Anon

No .... no I didn't :D Thanks for sharing that with us.

David

I would agree on that thought.

Andrew

I'm sure it wouldn't kill you chap, but yes I can see how you might have concerns buying it from somewhere you don't know where it came from.

Martin

If you buy them by the box you can get some very good rates can't you. I can't imagine making my way through 24+ bars of Mr Tom very quickly myself :D

Richard

I don't have the answer for you I'm afraid. That is something you will have to ask Hosta.

Lauren

Haha no I don't think it is I'm afraid.

Mysterio

Haha indeed you do have to watch the tooth pegs on them! They are a bit solid aren't they. I wouldn't blame you for passing up on this one.

Phil

I think this Mr Tom Chocolate probably suffered with the high standards that the Whittakers bar set. If you ever get the chance to try the Whittakers bar I would definitely give it a try if the proposition takes your fancy. This Mr Tom strikes me as the sort of thing you might be able to find in that Home Bargain shop you go to chap! Keep an eye out.

Alan

I'm not sure this is one you should get that concerned about not trying. There are so many other things I could suggest you try before worrying yourself about getting hold of a Mr Tom. I got a post coming up tomorrow that I hope you enjoy :D

Ali

Indeed! It's an old school saying but it's pretty true.

Mysterio

What does 'FTW' mean again? Look at the review chap, this wasn't your normal Mr Tom experience! You might be disappointed by it.

Thanks for the comments everyone. As I have said to Alan above I have a bit of a special post for this weekend. I hope you all enjoy it - it took an excessive amount of calorie consumption over the past few weeks to put it together :D

JIM

 

blogger templates | Make Money Online