
If you have been keeping tabs on the site this month you will have seen me working my way through the different price tiers of Thorntons' selection boxes. If you need reminding, I started off by reviewing their pretty dismal standard Chocolate Selection (See HERE), then moved on to their Premium Chocolate Selection (See HERE). Today I bring you my review of their Continental Selection, a box I bought in it's 175.0g form, priced at £7.50 in my local Thorntons shop.
This Continental Selection came billed as 'pralines, truffles and mousses covered in milk, white and dark chocolate with Swiss, Belgian, Spanish, Italian and French influences', and supposedly contained fourteen pieces. I say supposedly as I was denied trying one of their Pistachio Marzipan chocolates, which was unfortunately nowhere to be seen. I have to say it was one of the of the pieces that stood out to me when I looked in the snazzy menu included in the pack, so I was disappointed not to see it included. Speaking of the presentation, this was a very nice looking box of chocolates and I liked the subtly and elegance of both the box design and the inner truffles.
Plenty of pieces to get through so lets get on with it ...
Alpini - This milk chocolate covered piece hosted a centre of hazelnut and almond praline, and was decorated by a light dusting of white chocolate. The textures of the crisp chocolate, exterior dusting and slightly gritty filling were pleasant, but the nuttiness of the praline was disappointing and was overawed by the sweetness of the outer chocolate. Standard.Vanille Truffle - The outer white chocolate of this truffle made for a delicious creamy taste that led smoothly in to the bourbon noted truffle centre. Compared to the plainer filling pieces this flavoured one was more progressive and richer in taste as it detracted from the sugaryness sweetness and left a longing vanilla note in the mouth. Very Good.
Chocolate Truffle - I liked the aesthetic appeal and soft, sensuous textures offered by this chocolate, but unfortunately it didn't quite have the taste to match it's appearance. Although differentiated in terms of it's silky feel, the milk chocolate truffle centre was still equally as sugary sweet as the others. Standard.
Ganache Au Marc De Champagne - An absolutely fantastic chocolate! This was one of the finest champagne truffles I have tried - even up their with Hotel Chocolat's. The crisp outer chocolate shell led beautifully into the creamy, champagne noted cream below. The champagne volume was well measured and tickled the tongue to leave a lasting impression in the mouth. Spot on. Superb.Vienesse Truffle - Every chocolate selection has it's dud and this was no exception. Remember when I reviewed this in it's bar form (See Here)? Unfortunately I was given a stark reminder when I tried this. Flavourless and bland. Very Poor.
Valencia - The Spanish influenced chocolate in this selection proved to be one of the best, and I loved this dark chocolate covered orange flavoured truffle centre piece. The dark chocolate coating really made the difference here and provided a beautifully contrastive unsweetened cocoa taste that was enhanced delightfully by the sweet orangey syrup held withing. A delightful fruity chocolate. Very Good.
Sicilian Lemon Mousse - This was another I have tried previously in bar form so I knew exactly what to expect here. As I perceived then, the white chocolate outer portion was delicious, but the inner mousse filling was unsubstantial and lacking the desired lemony zest. Still one that will satisfy white chocolate fans though. Good.Catalana - This was one of the finer pieces in the entire selection and displayed a terrific amount of different textural elements for such a small truffle. The outer chocolate was further crisped by some tiny honeycomb pieces, whilst the inner caramel noted truffle was further supplemented by the most terrific smooth cream layer at the base. I delight for it's progressive cream and caramel flavours, as well as it's luxurious mouth presence. Superb.
Cappuccino - A complete carbon copy of the Caffee Latte piece included in the Thorntons Premium Collection (See Here). To repeat myself from there 'the coffee flavours were tasty, but mild mannered amongst the sweeter cocoa flavours that developed. Good.
Hazelnut Slice - As you can see from the photo, this was the piece that was portioned twice instead of the Pistachio Marzipan. Although I would rather of had the pistachio chocolate, this was a decent enough replacement, and unlike some of the other nut enhanced chocolates the hazelnut actually managed to cut through in the taste to a reasonable degree with it's woody influence. Texturally a little dry. Good.Mousse Au Chocolat - I groaned when I saw this on the menu! This was a filler piece for the box i.e. an uncomplicated, generic chocolate included for the sole reason to take up space. Just as I thought it was pretty unexciting - sweet milk chocolate with a light, non-progressive chocolate mousse centre. If they had portioned this twice I would have been very annoyed. Standard.
Diplomat - 'Traditionally when one Continental diplomat exchanged a gift with another, it was custom for the present to be wrapped in a gold leaf' .... what!?? Unfortunately reshaping and wrapping the Alpini chocolate didn't make it any different :D Standard.Cherry Truffle - We end on a high note here. The unsweetened dark chocolate shell, sour fruity cherry puree and sweet chocolate truffle centre made for a wonderful flavour and textural experience. I wasn't expecting to think that much of this chocolate but I really liked it. Very Good.
Overall this wasn't the best chocolate selection box in the world, but it was a noticeable step up in quality from the other two Thorntons boxes I tried earlier in the month. Whilst there were both 'filler' and missing pieces included in the selection, I would say the variety on offer was still very good, and it did contain a decent array of fruit, nut and caramels with different chocolate type exteriors. Priced at £7.00 I think this box comes in at half the price of the likes of Hotel Chocolat's selections and only a few pounds more than the Thorntons Premium Collection. On that basis I would tentatively suggest them as a sound option for gifting if you are in need of a chocolate selection box. I would suspect that moderate expectations would be exceeded.
8.2 out 10










54 comments:
Have Thorntons got you on their books now Jim :) This is their fourth review already this year if we count the mango one lol.
Nice one I say. The more British chocolate reviews from the likes of you the healthier it is for our companies.
----
Credit where credit is due. I have been pretty critical of Thorntons in my comments recently, but this looks like it is a half decent selection box.
The chocs I would really like to try are the Catalana and Cherry Truffle. You seem to praise them quite a bit above the others. Its such a shame you didn't get to see what the marzipan was like. Did you not think of downgrading them for not including it? lol I would of.
Phew lol I'm relieved for you that you thought this was better than the others. I don't like the reviews where you get all angry because things haven't matched your expectations.
It always brings the idiots commenting on here.
Rxxx
These are the best pictures ever. They are so clear.
I like the look of a lot of the chocolates but its the valencia one that stands head and shoulders above the rest for me. If someone in the know let me know if I can buy them on their own that would be great. I'm a big fan of orange truffles you see. There aren't too many good ones about.
I dont know if you were aware of this but the continental thorntons has been around for years. This isn't a new selection by any means, I remember having it years ago.
I think they might have updated some of the flavours, but its the dessert galleries and metropolitan selections that are the newest. Have you given them a thought?
I admire your persistance with Thorntons, its not like they have filled you with confidence with the other boxed chocolates you showed us recently. At least it came off for you this time. Judging by your stunning photos this continental lot must have been a load better.
That is really unfair they didn't give you the pistachio marzipan. Did you consider taking it back to the shop to get it replaced. I would of have done, its just not acceptable.
I would like: All the chocolate truffle ones lol, Valenica, Vanille Catalana
I wouldn't like: Lemon, Coffee, Champagne, Cherry
Thats a ratio of about 3:1 so I think thats pretty good. I would give the ones I dont like to my sister to give her shut up :) I can see myself buying this now. Thanks for the review Jim boy.
Seven pounds is an awesome price looking at this. I do love Hotel Chocolat but you have to admit Jim that all their chocolate is very expensive.
I know Thorntons do some pretty crap stuff nowadays but this just goes to show that they can still offer good value and high quality when they want to. That hazelnut slice choc looks epic btw. I wouldn't have been that upset if it had been portioned twice in a box I got.
All I have to say is lucky Man U again this weekend. You couldn't even beat Southampton more than 2-1. You ride your luck so much, you so nearly lost.
Do you think there will be any big money transfers today then? I fully expect that traitor Torres to make his way to Chelsea. The lack of loyalty is disgusting, I certainly wouldn't be buying Mr Torres a box of chocolates like these if I ever met him lol.
He more deserves to suffer with the nestle dairy box or cadburys milk tray.
Talk about being generous mate. How can you give an 8/10 for selection when there are about four that are exactly the same? Inconsistency to the tenth degree.
I had to leave a comment about your photography today Jim, all the ones of the chocolates are utterly fantastic again.
Your review of the diplomat chocolate made me laugh out loud :-) Why do these companies write stuff like that. Just tell us what the chocolate is sheesh.
Dx
Lmao you do hate that Vienesse truffle thing they make dont you. I had the bar once and didn't think it was as bad as you said tbh, I defo would never of given it the same rating you did put it that way.
Allejuhah 8.2! A Thorntons box of chocolates truley worth buying? Im there! I'm buying this soon as.
What happened to your awards?
Such high praise for their champagne truffle? Well well well I might have to go buy me some of them to investigate this. I love champagne truffles, I have eaten so many I would consider myself an expert lol.
Overall this wasn't the best chocolate selection box in the world, but it was a noticeable step up in quality from the other two Thorntons boxes I tried earlier in the month. Whilst there were both 'filler' and missing pieces included in the selection, I would say the variety on offer was still very good, and it did contain a decent array of fruit, nut and caramels with different chocolate type exteriors. Priced at £7.00 I think this box comes in at half the price of the likes of Hotel Chocolat's selections and only a few pounds more than the Thorntons Premium Collection.
I would have guessed that this would have cost over £10 if you hadn't of told us the price. Mark me as impressed. It makes that yucky looking classic collection looking embarrassing now. Your photos are a bit good today :P Thats praise coming from me so you kno they must be good lol :P
Will you be running a competition this week? What are the details?
@Midgley44
I can't eat Thorntons praline chocolates anymore. Their idea of what a decent praline is compared to someone like Godiva or Galler, even Ritter, is a million miles away. They seem to think that just adding small bits of nut to a flavouress chocolate truffle is worthy of being called it. Its a far greater art than that.
The lemon mousse scillian bar is so nice but they make it in such small bars. If I ever buy them now I have to get the packs of four because one of them on their own is pathetic.
They need to at least double the size of them. Nice review lad. I'll jump on the 'nice photos' bandwagon lol.
A positive Thorntons review? Boy there is a first thing for everything. Too bad about the other hundreds you have written already disgracing one of our own. Its a bit late now.
£7??? Are you sure?
I don't think you could argue with that. It looks suitably priced if you ask me lad.
You said ages ago that you didn't drink much?
Isn't it a bit odd that your favourite was the only one to have alcohol in? I think you are kidding yourself Jimbob you boozehound j/k
How the hell do you get such nice looking photography done? I've tried recreating the sort of shots you do with truffles before and all I have done is created a big mess :-) You have to cheat somehow! Do you freeze them or summit?
What is the difference between the lemon mousse and the vanilla truffle in the premiuim box? I knew I had seen that chocolate before and I just checked the old review and they look identical.
For once I think you might have overstated a Thorntons product. You look like you might have been too generous with your taste and selection ratings of 8. You don't exactly give out that many quips of anything better than 'Good' all that much, and you do complain that some of the pieces are too similar (which I would agree with you looking at them).
I hope people complaining about your previous posts haven't influenced you in to giving a better score. You're better than that.
@Nigel @Jim ----> Could Spurs try buy more strikers if they tried? lol im a spurs fan.
Since you last posted that review of the premium chocolates I did buy them to see what they were like.
My own problem with them as such was a few of them tasted the same and in that I mean they weren't as strongly flavoured to what they were supposed to be (pralines espec). I think your rating was fair.
As for these if was going to buy Thorntons again I would consider giving this continental box a try. The chocolates look better and by the sounds of it they aren't that much more expensive.
The problem with thorntons now is that they have so much other rubbish people never buy the decent stuff like this one. Its their own fault for being money grabbing wotsits. They sold themselves out.
I expected a low score when I saw the title, but hurrah, for once Thorntons score well! :)
This sounds quite decent, but I really dislike "filler" chocolates, like the alpini that was portioned again in the gold wrapper (lol at the diplomat nonsense), and the mousse au chocolat. I mean anyone can make a chocolate with a chocolate mousse filling. Apart from those this sounds quite good, the valencia orange and cherry truffle in particular.
@Lauren - I have to agree. Most pralines are rubbish, but European companies such as Ritter and Ferrero seem to have mastered the art of making them.
Those are some really outstanding photos. You must have amazing patience to get them all looking the same like that.
Its funny how the Spanish themed chocolates are the best sounding when we don't associate Spain with chocolate ever.
Where are the German influenced pieces? I would of thought they would of had more of a say in a continental collection. Its a real pity about the pistachio marzipan.
These sound really nice I have to say! I think I'd enjoy the orange truffle most and the pther fruity ones, except the cherry one which I could do without lol.
Personally I dont see anything really wrong with the Mousse au Chocolat, it sounds nice enough and I'd rather have that the cherry (or the Diplomat! lol). The Diplomat slogan sounds like its out of the 60's, I've noticed alot of advertising used dodgy 'stories' or slogans like that :P
I might start dropping some hints to my husband that I wouldn't mind trying these. Hes normally pretty good picking up on my non to subtle whisperings.
Oh dear it also contains nuts. The children wont be able to indulge. What a shame ;)
Finally a box of chocs from these guys worth bothering with. Not that I have ever seen it mind.
The only Thorntons boxed chocolates I ever see on sale is that premium collection.
Its not everyday we see a recommendation of a thorntons product from you Jim. Im not saying that in a critical way, Im just making the point that this box must be really good. There are a few in there that I know I wouldn't like, but I think there are more than enough to justify a purchase someday. Especially if I see it knocking around on the cheap.
I remember seeing this a while ago and thinking it looked great. Then again, a lot of presentation photos are deceiving... Looking at your pictures today, I can say that, while the chocolates don't look quite like in those presentation photos, they don't look bad at all. The Sicilian Lemon Mousse, the Viennese Truffle, the Mousse au Chocolat and the Cherry Truffle look particularly nice.
The flavours aren't anything crazy, which is good in a certain way, because there's nothing in there that would make me think "there's no way I'm touching that!"
Actually, most of them make me think "yes, I want to try that!"
I love the yummy pictures. I need some chocs now.
It looks like you get a right old mixture here. Some of these chocolates look all complicated and layered and stuff, whilst others look just really boring.
For my liking there are too many of the boring ones likes the diplomat, mousse and hazelnut slice. They all look the same but just reshaped.
They should of had more like the Valencia and the Catalan.
I bought this exact same box about a year ago and it looked nothing like that.
I would say it looks ten times better now. Before it looked much the same as the premium box you have linked in. I think they have made a wise decision getting them seperated as these are a lot better imo.
Hi All,
I thought I better respond to you guys tonight as I know I will be rushed off my feet tomorrow.
It was a delight reviewing this box of chocolates. It was by no means perfect, but it was a better experience than what I got from the other two Thorntons boxes this month.
Thanks to everyone for the nice words about the photography on the review today. The pressure was on when I was doing these ones as there was only one of each in the box!
Nick - People did ask for more reviews from British manufactures.
Golden - I assumed that it was just a one off mistake so I didn't want to be too harsh on them.
Paul - There is a review of the Metropolitan selection knocking about. The desserts Gallery is on my request list so expect it soon.
Estelle - By the time I realised the pistachio was missing I had cut up must the other pieces. I don't think they would have taken it back haha :D
Nigel - Luck is nothing to do with it chap :D You make your own lucky anyway! Amazing scenes in the transfer deadline day huh!? Andy Carroll £35.0m? You have to be kidding me :D
Anon - There were similar pieces, but there was also still a wide variety.
Anon #2 - Awards are coming Feb 19th.
Anon #3 - No competition this week as far as I know chap. Keep an eye on Twitter though ;D
Lewis - Check their website if you don't deliver me chap :D
Justin - I honestly don't drink that often. The champagne truffle was very good. Try it yourself and tell me what you think, they must sell it on their own over the counters in their shops.
Andrew - If I get the chance I do chill them. More often then not though I just try use the right sort of flat edge knife.
Hollie - Haha well one is vanilla flavoured and the other is Lemon flavoured :D Sorry to sound cheeky but it's the truth. You are right though they do look identical.
David - You know me chap I just say what I think. No matter who I am reviewing, or who says what.
Joel - Thanks Joel. It's always nice to get 2nd opinions on these things.
Phil - Hey Thorntons score highly all the time what you on about chap :D This box was odd in that it contained a load of different chocolates, but then 3/4 that were so similar. The fruit ones you mention were especially good. I think you are right about leaving the pralines to the other European countries, they seem to know what they are doing.
Chris - I guess the German one was supposed to be the pralines and the marzipan. It was a real shame about the marzipan indeed.
Alan - The Diplomat was such a corny chocolate :D It really did make me cringe when I saw that description in the menu. Especially when it became obvious it wasn't all that different from so many of the others.
Ana - The flavours are sensible and well balanced aren't they. There certainly aren't any in there that would put people off buying the box. What I think they have done well is that they have made something for everyone in there. Its a well rounded selection.
Tim - I had no idea it had been around so long until some of you guys mentioned it today. I thought it was a relatively new selection. It must just be the box and presentation that is different.
Thank you for all the comments girls and guys. Some of you were way too kind about the photos etc :D All that praise and there isn't even a competition on the go haha! You must all genuinely think they are good :D Thats nice to hear.
Anyway, plenty more to come this week.
JIM
Is there a fourth tier you are going to try then :) Whats next from Thorntons?
You really have to stop making these chocolates look so scrummy Jim. Its almost impossible to stick to a diet an =d still view this site. The temptation is just too much, my chocolate cravings are going through the roof.
@Jim Ok I get you didn't want to be harsh. If you found out that they had stopped making the pistachio marzipan and it wasn't included in any of the boxes not just yours, would you have changed your score then. Has anyone else had it missing?
I have eyed this box up a few times in the past but I never bought it because it doesn't tell you what flavours it has on the outside. I never get why so many chocolate boxes dont do that.
If im going to to buy a box of chocolates the least I want to know is what is actually included in there lol. They need to list them out to tell people whats in there.
EPIC amounts of win for the pictures. That catalana looks amaze.
At least you gave thorntons a fair crack of the whip for once. You should stop reviewing so many dodgy foriegn chocolates and keep it to the british makes.
Can I put in some thorntons requests please? Where and who do I send them to?
@Wendy the best place to put requests is the Requests page (tab at the top of the blog). Jim will add them to the list :)
On a diffrent topic all together, has anyone seen the new look Cadbury Dairy Milk Tasters? The first wrapper change in their history! lol The ingredients are a bit different aswell!
When I come onto the site and see Thorntons I never know what to expect as they are so bi-polar nowadays (been a bit more down than up lately), so I'm always intruiged with what you're going to say. I'm glad that just by looking at these chocolates, they look far better than the premium box and look as though some effort has been put into it. I've not tried these before but a few of these do tempt me (cherry truffle, hazelnut slice, catalana (certainly put the effort in with this one), valencia, alpini & vanilla truffle). I might pick up a box next time I'm passing by. Such a shame that there was a mistake and the pistachio marzipan was missing as this sounds like the most interesting and different piece. It would have been interesting just to see what it looked like as pistachio chocolates tend to stand out appearance wise.
Thanks for the review and the photos looks great. I love the cross sections of selection box chocolates. Now that you seem to be making a dent in the Thorntons selection boxes, do you have any more in the pipeline?
@Alan did you take a photo of the new packet? Its always nice to see a new wrapper :)
Great review Jim. The guys are right you out did yourself with the pics today. They all look so delicious.
I'm pretty sure I remember the same thing happening to me when I had these chocolates. I had them as a Christmas present last year, and was surprised to find two of the same chocolate in there, with one from the menu missing. I can't remember if it is the same one you were missing, but it probably was.
Post a Comment